The Elizabethan Church
by Heather Thomas
Essential Background Information:
The Henrician Church (Click to Read, Click to Close)
Before Henry VIII quarreled with the Pope and established the Church of England, England had been a faithful Catholic country for centuries. In the days before the annulling of his first marriage became such a political issue throughout Europe, Henry too had been a faithful Catholic, and had earned the title of "Defender of the Faith" for writing a piece of work against the new Protestant religion. But when it became clear to Henry that he would not have a son by Catherine of Aragon, he was determined to have his marriage to her annulled, so that he could re-marry and father a son to succeed him.
What Henry had to do to secure this, changed the course of English history forever. Catherine of Aragon would not agree to an annulment, which would make her daughter, Mary, illegitimate and unable to succeed to the throne, arguing that she was Henry's true wife, and had always been so. In Tudor times, there was no divorce as such - that is the dissolving of a legally valid marriage - and couples who wanted to part had to seek an annulment, which would be the acceptance that they were never truly married in the first place. An annulment could only be granted in certain circumstances - such as one or both of the partners had been too young to marry, or the marriage was not properly conducted, or the couple were too closely related by blood.
It was the latter that Henry initially used to try and obtain the annulment. Catherine had been the wife of his brother, Arthur, and after his premature death, married Henry. It said in the Bible that it was wrong for a man to marry his brother's wife, and if he did, they would have no children, and Henry interpreted this as the reason for his lack of sons. Henry put his case to the Pope who was in charge of annulling marriages, but did not get the response that he desired. Catherine was the aunt of the great Emperor Charles V, the most influential man in Europe, and knowing how Catherine felt about the annulment, the Pope could not afford to offend her great nephew.
Henry tried to secure an annulment from the Pope for a number of years, but the Pope was unrelenting. Henry realized that if he wanted to re-marry, he would have to find another way of annulling the marriage. He and his ministers found the solution in establishing a Church of England which would be totally independent of the Papacy. Protestants did not recognize the power of the Pope, and so Henry as King would be free to mould the church in whatever way he desired. Henry made himself "Supreme Head of the Church in England", and got his annulment, making him free to marry Anne Boleyn.
As head of the Church, Henry was effectively in charge of the Archbishops, Bishops and all the clergy that the English Church still retained. In fact, in many ways, the new English Church was very similar to the old Catholic Church. Henry was arguably a Catholic at heart, and changed the beliefs of the Church very little. But in other ways, the change of religion in England had enormous repercussions for the country. The monasteries and convents of the land, which had grown rich over the centuries, fell prey to Henry and his ministers, and were all closed. Henry was covetous of their wealth, and his ministers declared publicly thatÊ monks, nuns and friars were living immoral rather than godly lives, living lives of luxury rather than of humility and poverty that was expected of them, eating good food, drinking good wines, and even keeping mistresses and lovers. This was probably untrue in the majority of cases, and simply a propaganda tool by the government to justify their action against them.
Towards the end of his life, Henry began to turn once again to Catholicism, and his apprehension over the way he had treated the monks, nuns and friars, is reflected in his dying words, "monks, monks, monks".
The Marian Church (Click to Read, Click to Close)
Henry's Protestant son, King Edward VI, died when he was only sixteen. After an unsuccessful attempt by Northumberland to usurp the throne for his daughter in law, Lady Jane Grey, Henry VIII's eldest daughter, Mary, became Queen. Mary was a devoted Catholic, and from the outset of her reign, she was determined to restore the Catholic faith in England. This had been widely suspected, and it was this knowledge that was a large factor in Northumberland's schemes. The restoration of the Catholic faith also worried a significant proportion of the nobility. Many families had become wealthy as a result of the Reformation, having gained land from the dissolved monasteries, convents and friaries. The Protestant faith had also secularized certain aspects of local government, and the officials had no desire to lose their influence and prestige to the church. However, the majority of the common people were probably still Catholic, and there was by no means a lack of enthusiasm for the return of their old and familiar faith. Mary has been known in history as "Bloody Mary" because of her persecution of Protestants, but in 1553, persecution was not something she anticipated. Initially her reign was tolerant. Perhaps she believed that the people were longing so much for the return of her beloved faith that she would have no need to persecute, but time shattered her belief.
Mary replaced the Protestant clergy with Catholics, imprisoning prominent Protestants such as Cranmer, Latimer and Ridley. The Parliament of 1553 repealed most of the Protestant legislation of her brother, including the two Prayer books, Acts of Uniformity, the marriage of the clergy, and the Forty-two Articles. This did not occur without some dispute, and there was opposition over the government's attempt to punish those that refused to attend Catholic worship. The Act of Supremacy was later annulled, and in November 1554, absolution was granted to the whole realm by Cardinal Pole, the Pope's legate in England, and the country was restored to Papal obedience. Anti-Lollards acts were passed in Parliament, and all acts against the Papacy made since 1529 were annulled. Mary hoped to restore the monasteries, convents and Friars, but this proved more difficult, and the government had to concede that the lands given out to the nobility during the years of change, remained theirs. Seminaries were established to train priests. Protestant books were replaced with Catholic ones, there was an attempt to restore statues and paintings in churches, as well as the altar and the great crucifixes that had also been removed, and the vestments worn by the clergy.
In 1555, the persecution of Protestants began. Those who refused to adhere to the Catholic form of worship were to be burnt to death as heretics. It was this above all else - even the Queen's marriage to Philip II - that made the first Tudor Queen so unpopular. Mary appears to have been the driving force in the persecution, believing that the more people she burnt for heresy, the more favor she would receive from God. Mary desperately wanted a baby, and when she failed to have one, she saw this as a sign from God that she was being too tolerant of Protestantism, and the result was more burnings. Some of her advisors were aware of the damage her policy was causing her and her government, but Mary was persistent. Some three hundred people were burnt to death between 1555 and 1558. Most of the people were Londoners, but there were also burnings in Kent, Essex, Sussex and Suffolk. Cranmer, Latimer and Ridley were also burnt for heresy, and other lesser clergy. Many people were horrified, especially when a pregnant woman was burnt to death. In these years, Elizabeth became increasingly popular, and a poem was later dedicated to her:
"When these with violence were burnt to death,
We prayed to God for our Elizabeth."
Burning for heresy was a well established custom in the country - no one disputed it, and a small number of heretics were also burnt in Elizabeth's reign, but the objection under Mary was the definition of heresy. Protestantism had a strong following in the country, and it was accepted by many as a legitimate form of Christian worship, and not at all heretical.
Queen Elizabeth and the Church
When Elizabeth became Queen in the November of 1558, it was widely believed that she would restore the Protestant faith in England. Mary's persecution of Protestants had done much damage to the standing of Catholicism in England, and the number of Protestants in the country was steadily increasing. Although Elizabeth had adhered to the Catholic faith during her sister's reign, she had been raised a Protestant, and was committed to that faith. Elizabeth's religious views were remarkably tolerant for the age in which she lived. She believed sincerely in her own faith, but she also believed in religious toleration, and that Catholics and Protestants were both part of the same faith. "There is only one Christ, Jesus, one faith" she exclaimed later in her reign, "all else is a dispute over trifles." She also declared that she had "no desire to make windows into men's souls".
Throughout her reign, Elizabeth's main concern was the peace and stability of the realm, and religious persecution was only adopted when certain religious groups threatened this peace. It was unfortunate for Elizabeth that so many of her contemporaries did not share her views on toleration, and she was forced by circumstance to adopt a harsher line towards Catholics than she intended or wanted. Elizabeth's toleration of Catholics, and her refusal to make changes to the Church she established in 1559, has led some historians to doubt her commitment to her faith - even to assert that she was an atheist, but such statements are misleading. Elizabeth wanted a Church that would appeal to both Catholics and Protestants, and did not want to move the Church in a more Protestant direction, thus making it more difficult for Catholics to accept the Church than it was already. The form of worship also suited the Queen's conservative religion. She had little sympathy with Protestant extremists who wanted to strip the Church of it's finery, ban choral music, vestments and bell ringing, and liked her Church just the way it was.
Elizabethan hoped that by retaining the Church as it was, people would become accustomed to it. She wanted her Church to be popular with her people, and for Catholicism to die out naturally as people turned to the religion she had established. In this she was largely successful, for by 1603, the English nation as a population were generally Protestant, and Catholics were in the minority. Elizabeth had her own private chapel in most of her palaces, and reputedly prayed there everyday. She saw herself as God's vessel on earth, and would pray to determine God's will so that he would reveal it to her, and she could implement it. Although Elizabeth's actual beliefs elude us, we are able to get an indication of them from her attitudes and gestures. Her chapels were conservative - the crucifix was displayed, and she also liked candles and music. She disliked long Protestant sermons, but also expressed displeasure at some Catholic rituals such as the elevation of the host, which implied that she rejected the Catholic belief of transubstantiation. She also did not really approve of the clergy marrying as she expressed on several occasions, but as this was an integral aspect of Protestantism, she had to accept it.
A more personal indication of her beliefs are the prayers she wrote for her people, and the letters she wrote to her friends and relations. In these letters she often referred to God and the need to accept his will. In her prayers she also acknowledged her own faults and shortcomings. Elizabeth was by no means the perfect Protestant by the standards of many of her clergy - she swore terribly, using expressions that some thought were blasphemous, one of her favorite being "God's Death", and her sumptuous appearance was criticized by the more radical Protestants, known as "Puritans", who accused her of vanity and idolatry - but there is no reason to doubt that the Queen was a committed Protestant who took her faith seriously.
A Prayer by Queen Elizabeth I
"O Most Glorious King, and Creator of the whole world, to whom all things be subject, both in heaven and earth, and all best Princes most gladly obey. Hear the most humble voice of thy handmaid, in this only happy, to be so accepted. How exceeding is thy goodness, and how great mine offences. Of nothing hast thou made me not a worm, but a Creature according to thine own image, heaping all the blessings upon me that men on earth hold most happy. Drawing my blood from kings and my bringing up in virtue; giving me that more is, even in my youth knowledge of thy truth: and in times of most danger, most gracious deliverance: pulling me from the prison to the palace: and placing me a Sovereign Princess over thy people of England. And above all this, making me (though a weak woman) yet thy instrument, to set forth the glorious Gospel of thy dear Son Christ Jesus.
"Thus, in these last and worst days of the world, when wars and seditions with grievous persecutions have vexed almost all Kings and Countries, round about me, my reign hath been peaceable, and my realm a receptacle to thy afflicted church. The love of my people hath appeared firm, and the devices of mine enemies frustrate. Now for these and other thy benefits (O Lord of all goodness) what have I rendered to thee? Forgetfulness, unthankfulness and great disobedience. I should have magnified thee, I have neglected thee. I should have prayed unto thee, I have forgotten thee. I should have served thee, I have sinned against thee. This is my case. Then where is my hope? If thou Lord wilt be
extreme to mark what is done amiss, who may abide it? But thou art gracious and merciful, long suffering and of great goodness, not delighting in the death of a Sinner. Thou seest whereof I came, of corrupt seed: what I am, a most frail substance: where I live in the world full of wickedness: where delights be snares, where dangers be imminent, where sin reigneth, and death abideth.
"This is my state. Now where is my comfort? In the depth of my misery I know no help (0 Lord) but the height of thy mercy, who hast sent thine only Son into the world to save sinners. This God of my life and life of my soul, the King of all comfort, is my only refuge. For his sake therefore, to whom thou hast given all power, and wilt deny no petition, hear my prayers. Turn thy face from my sins (0 Lord) and thine eyes to thy handiwork. Create a clean heart, and renew a right spirit within me. Order my steps in thy word, that no wickedness have dominion over me, make me obedient to thy will, and delight in thy law. Grant me grace to live godly and to govern justly: that so living to please thee, and reigning
to serve thee I may ever glorify thee, the Father of all goodness and mercy. To whom with thy dear Son, my only Saviour, and the Holy Ghost my Sanctifier, three persons and one God: be all praise, dominion and power, world without end. AMEN."
The Elizabethan Religious Settlement
Like her father, Elizabeth was a Protestant. When she first became Queen, one of the first things it was necessary for her to do, was restore the Protestant Church of England. Events that led to the restoration of the Church of England is known as "The Elizabeth Religious Settlement". It was comprised of two acts - "The Act of Supremacy" and The Act of Uniformity.
The Act of Supremacy (Click to Read, Click to Close)
It was this act that gave Elizabeth ultimate control of the Church of England. In the reign of her father and brother, the monarch had been "Head of the Church in England", but under Elizabeth, this was modified to "Supreme Governor of the Church in England". The change may have been made to appease Catholics who could not accept the monarch as "Head of the Church", seeing the church as the Pope's domain, or it may have been made because Elizabeth was a woman. In the sixteenth century, women were regarded as inferior to men in spiritual matters, and many were uncomfortable with the idea of a woman being in charge. This act also included an oath of loyalty to the Queen that the clergy were expected to take. If they did not take it, then they would lose their office. A High Commission was established to ensure that the oath was taken. The oath was as follows:
"I A. B. do utterly testify and declare in my conscience, That the Queen's Highness is the only Supream Governor of this Realm, and of all other her Highness Dominions and Countries, as well in all Spiritual or Ecclesiastical Things or Causes, as Temporal; and that no foreign Prince, Person, Prelate State or Potentate, hath or ought to have any Jurisdiction, Power, Superiority, Preheminence, or Authority Ecclesiastical or Spiritual, within this Realm; and therefore I do utterly renounce and forsake all foreign Jurisdictions, Powers, Superiorities and Authorities, and do promote, that from henceforth I shall bear faith and true Allegiance to the Queen's Highness, her Heirs and lawful Successors, and to my Power shall asssist and defend all Jurisdictions, Preheminences, Privileges and Authorities granted or belonging to the Queen's Highness, her Heirs and Successors, or united and annexed to the Imperial Crown of this Realm. So help me God, and by the Contents of this Book."
The Act of Uniformity (Click to Read, Click to Close)
This was the crux of the Elizabethan Church, establishing a set form of worship. The Prayer books of Edward VI were fused into one, and were to be used in every church in the land. Church attendance on Sundays and holy days was made compulsory, with a twelve pence fine to be collected if people did not attend, the money to be given to the poor. The wording of the Communion was to be vague so that Protestants and Catholics could both participate, and the ornaments and vestments of the Church were to be retained as they had been before the reforms in the second year of Edward's reign. Although the passage of the Act of Supremacy through Parliament had been relatively easy, passing the Act of Uniformity was much more difficult. A large number of the Parliament, who were still Catholic, opposed the bill, and it was eventually only passed by three votes, 21 to 18.
The religious settlement began to be implemented in the summer of 1559. Despite the problems that sometimes arose, it proved to be a remarkable success.
Archbishops of Canterbury
Although both the Archbishops of Canterbury and York were influential, the Archbishop of Canterbury was regarded as the superior. During her long reign, Elizabeth had three:
Matthew Parker (1559-1575) (Click to Read, Click to Close)
Parker began his life as a Catholic, but was converted to Protestantism while at Cambridge University. He was favored by both Henry VIII and Edward VI. He became Queen Elizabeth's first Archbishop of Canterbury in 1559. He was largely responsible for implementing the Elizabethan religious settlement and monitoring abuses within the Church. He was a man dedicated to his work, and earned the title of "Nosy Parker" for his interference in people's affairs. He and Elizabeth did not always see eye to eye on religious matters, and both had to compromise their views in order to work together. Early in her reign, Elizabeth expressed a dislike of the clergy marrying. In 1561 she issued a royal
injunction forbidding any cleric to live with his wife and family in any cathedral close or college. This was not popular, and Parker, who was married himself, defended clerical marriage. The Queen relented over the cathedral closes, but not the colleges. Elizabeth was also concerned that the religious settlement was not being properly observed in some areas outside London, and she blamed Parker for not ensuring that the act of uniformity was properly enforced.
Edmund Grindal (1575-83) (Click to Read, Click to Close)
Although Elizabeth's relationship with Archbishop Parker was not always easy, they worked well together, and put the Elizabethan Church on a firm foothold. They had differences of opinion, but this was perhaps inevitable, and the strength of the partnership can be seen in the success of the Church in the early years, and that Parker remained in his office until his death in 1575. Elizabeth's relationship with his successor, Edmund Grindal, was disastrous. Until Parker's death, he had been Archbishop of York and was well thought of and admired. the problem with Grindal was that he had some Puritan sympathies, and wished the Church to be more overtly Protestant.
Almost immediately he began to make changes, and allowed the publication of the Protestant Geneva Bible, which had been suppressed by Parker. His actions soon irritated the Queen. She wanted every church in the land to worship God as the religious settlement dictated, and did not want any change made to the settlement, or for the church to be pushed in a more fervent Protestant direction. She liked the settlement just as it was, and didn't want to change it. She and Grindal soon clashed over the matter of "prophesyings", and it was the Archbishop who came out worse for wear. Prophesyings were unauthorized meetings for prayer and preaching. These concerned Elizabeth who felt that the preachers would preach what ever came into their head, not what was sound doctrine. Not only would this undermine her Church, but could also be dangerous, as there was no control over what would be said, or the issues that could arise.
Elizabeth was deeply suspicious of Puritans and their dislike of hierarchy, and was concerned that what began as religious talk could quickly become political. Such preachers, she felt, would also make people discontentedÊ with her Church and heighten what was already a very tense religious situation. As well as facing opposition to the Church from Puritans, she also faced a very dangerous opposition from the Catholics. Elizabeth believed that all the preachers of the realm should preach according to the regulations of her Church, preach the same message and doctrine, and read from approved books of homilies and prayers. This would unite the country, not divide it.
In 1576, she ordered Grindal to suppress the prophesyings. However, Grindal was very much in favor of them. He believed that they were a good way of educating the people into the doctrine of the new faith, and for providing religious instruction, as some places were without ministers. He consulted his bishops over the matter, and finding that ten out of fifteen approved of them, he felt obliged to write to the Queen to tell her that he thought they were a good idea. His letter to her was remarkably bold, as were his further petitions. He told her that although she was the highest authority in the land over political matters, she did not have the same authority over spiritual matters, and that he must put the will of God above his duty to her as sovereign. Elizabeth was outraged at his defiance, and he was suspended from his office in the summer of 1577 until his death in 1583.
John Whitgift (1583-1604) (Click to Read, Click to Close)
John Whitgift (1583-1604)Of all her Archbishops of Canterbury, John Whitgift was the one that Elizabeth got on the best with. He shared many of her views and aspirations, and as well as this, was unmarried. Like Elizabeth, he was suspicious of Puritans, and was eager to defend the Elizabethan Church against this religious group, as well as protect it against the machinations of the Catholics. He was a devoted Anglican, and pushed for obedience to the English Church. Elizabeth affectionately called him her "little black husband". When she lay on her death-bed, she drew comfort from his presence, and his prayers for her immortal soul.
The Elizabethan Church and Catholics
Catholics did not have an easy time during the reign of Elizabeth, but many of them would have agreed that things could have been much worse. Catholicism was effectively illegal, but it was for not attending church that Catholics were fined, not for simply being Catholic, and the fine applied to dissenting Puritans as well as to those of the Catholic faith.
In 1559, a 12 pence fine for refusing to go to church was created, and the loss of office for Catholic clergy refusing to take the oath of supremacy. Attendance at mass was to be punished by a fine of 100 marks, but theÊ saying of mass, or arranging for it to be said, carried the death penalty, although Elizabeth ensured that this was never implemented before 1577 as she disliked such extremism. As far as Elizabeth was concerned, so long as Catholics behaved themselves, were loyal to her, and attended church now and then, they were free to believe what they wished. Elizabeth tried to accommodate Catholic beliefs in her religious settlement so that they could go to church without feeling guilty or disloyal to their faith, and often turned a blind eye to Catholics who had secret services in their home. There was no attempt to ruthlessly seek out Catholics, and no desire to put ordinary men and women to death simply for their faith.
It was only as the Catholic threat against Elizabeth from Europe heightened as the reign progressed, that the Elizabethan government had to take a harsher stance against Catholics than they had initially anticipated. Some of Elizabeth's ministers, such as Sir Francis Walsingham, were zealously committed to the Protestant cause and wished to persecute Catholics in England, but their ambitions were always held in check by the Queen. For the first decade of the reign, the Catholics suffered little. It was not until the Papal Bull of 1570 that the situation changed.
The new pope, Pius V, did not like Elizabeth. Like all Catholics, he believed she was illegitimate, and thus had no right to the throne of England. Catholics believed that the true Queen of the land was Mary Queen of Scots. In 1570 he issued a bull "Regnans in Excelsis" (a papal document) against Elizabeth, that excommunicated her and absolved all her subjects from allegiance to her and her laws. This was a drastic step, and one that was not approved of by Philip II of Spain, or some English Catholics, who knew that this would make things difficult for Catholics in England. Excommunication was a great disgrace to Catholics. An excommunicated person was not to be dealt with, as it was believed that they were unchristian and would go to hell.
The excommunication of Elizabeth must have been a very painful experience for her Catholic subjects. They were cruelly torn between two loyalties - loyalty to the Queen many of them respected, if not loved, and loyalty to the Pope who they believed was God's representative on Earth. Many Catholics probably never solved the dilemma, ignored it, or remained loyal to both, separating their spiritual and secular allegiances. From this moment on, Catholics were seen as a great threat to the Queen and the realm.
The plots against Elizabeth's life that occurred from the 1570's onwards also did much to fossil the idea that Catholics were traitors, as did the continuous flow of Jesuit priests into the country. The entrance of Jesuits into the country was prohibited by law in 1585, but still they came in the hope of converting the English population to Catholicism. It was these who bore the brunt of the Catholic persecution. Many of them were executed for treason. William Cecil devised questions to be asked of English Jesuits and Priests, and the question over who they would support if the Pope invaded the country - Pope or Queen, was their down fall every time. This question became known as it is still known today, "The bloody question", as there was really only one answer that a true Catholic could give.
Politics and religion were so intricately connected in the Elizabethan period that it was difficult to determine one from the other. In 1581 an Act was passed that made it treason to withdraw English subjects from allegiance to the Queen or her Church, and fines for recusancy (refusing to go to church) were increased to twenty pounds - a phenomenal amount to the Elizabethans, considering that the annual income of a knight would only be about fifty pounds. The Elizabethan government genuinely believed that Catholics, particularly the Jesuits, posed a serious threat to the Queen's life and reign, and the literature produced by the leaders of the "English Mission" (an active campaign to restore Catholicism in the land and depose Elizabeth) such as William Allen and Robert Persons, seemed to confirm their suspicions.
-----------------------------------------
©2005 Heather Thomas - Visit her Website
---------------------------------------------------------
©2007 Britannia.com Web Design and Content Development by SightLines, Inc.
|